CAT 2017 Slot 1 — VARC Question 21
Answer the following question based on the information given below.
Scientists have long recognized the incredible diversity within a species. But they thought it reflected evolutionary changes that unfolded imperceptibly, over millions of years. That divergence between populations within a species was enforced, according to Ernst Mayr, the great evolutionary biologist of the 1940s, while a population was separated from the rest of the species by a mountain range or a desert, preventing breeding across the divide over geologic scales of time. Without the separation, gene flow was relentless. But as the separation persisted, the isolated population grew apart and speciation occurred.
In the mid – 1960s, the biologist Paul Ehrlich – author of the Population Bomb (1968) – and his Standford University colleagues Peter Raven Challenged Mayr’s ideas about speciation. They had studied checkerspot butterflies living in the Jasper Ridge Biological Preserve in California, and it soon became clear that they were not examining a single population. Through years of capturing, marking and then recapturing the butterflies, they were able to prove that within the population, spread over just 50 acres of suitable checkerspot habitat, there were three groups that interacted despite their very clear proximity.
Among other ideas, Ehrlich and Raven argued in a now classic paper from 1969 that gene flow was not as predictable and ubiquitous as Mayr and his cohort maintained, and thus evolutionary divergence between neighbouring groups in a population was probably common. They also asserted that isolation and gene flow were less important to evolutionary divergence than natural selection (when factors such as mate choice, weather, disease or predation cause better-adapted individuals to survive and pass on their successful genetic traits). For example, Ehrlich and Raven suggested that, without the force of natural selection, an isolated population would remain unchanged and that, in other scenarios, natural selection could be strong enough to overpower gene flow…
The author discusses Mayr, Ehrlich and Raven to demonstrate that
Answer & solution
- A
evolution is a sensitive and controversial topic.
- B
Ehrlich and Raven’s ideas about evolutionary divergence are widely accepted by scientists.
the cause of speciation are debated scientists.
- D
checkerspot butterflies offer the best example of Ehrlich and Raven’s ideas about speciation.
The scientists are in debate with each other over the fact that speciation occurs when species are isolated from each other. Mayr concluded in the first paragraph of the passage that when populations are isolated, speciation occurs. But Ehrlich and Raven observe that even though Checkerspot butterflies lived in close proximity, they did not interact with each other. This leads to a debate between the scientists.
Hence, option (c).