CAT 2022 Slot 1VARC Question 7

Mixed PracticeEasy
Passage / Data

The passage below is accompanied by a set of questions. Choose the best answer to each question.
Stories concerning the Undead have always been with us. From out of the primal darkness of Mankind’s earliest years, come whispers of eerie creatures, not quite alive (or alive in a way which we can understand), yet not quite dead either. These may have been ancient and primitive deities who dwelt deep in the surrounding forests and in remote places, or simply those deceased who refused to remain in their tombs and who wandered about the countryside, physically tormenting and frightening those who were still alive. Mostly they were ill-defined—strange sounds in the night beyond the comforting glow of the fire, or a shape, half-glimpsed in the twilight along the edge of an encampment. They were vague and indistinct, but they were always there with the power to terrify and disturb. They had the power to touch the minds of our early ancestors and to fill them with dread. Such fear formed the basis of the earliest tales although the source and exact nature of such terrors still remained very vague.

And as Mankind became more sophisticated, leaving the gloom of their caves and forming themselves into recognizable communities—towns, cities, whole cultures—so the Undead travelled with them,  nhabiting their folklore just as they had in former times. Now they began to take on more definite shapes. They became walking cadavers; the physical embodiment of former deities and things which had existed alongside Man since the Creation. Some still remained vague and ill-defined but, as Mankind strove to explain the horror which it felt towards them, such creatures emerged more readily into the light.

In order to confirm their abnormal status, many of the Undead were often accorded attributes, which defied the natural order of things—the power to transform themselves into other shapes, the ability to sustain themselves by drinking human blood, and the ability to influence human minds across a distance. Such powers—described as supernatural—only [lent] an added dimension to the terror that humans felt regarding them. 

And it was only natural, too, that the Undead should become connected with the practice of magic. From very early times, Shamans and witchdoctors had claimed at least some power and control over the spirits of departed ancestors, and this has continued down into more “civilized” times. Formerly, the invisible spirits and forces that thronged around men’s earliest encampments, had spoken “through” the tribal Shamans but now, as entities in their own right, they were subject to magical control and could be physically summoned by a competent sorcerer. However, the relationship between the magician and an Undead creature was often a very tenuous and uncertain one. Some sorcerers might have even become Undead entities once they died, but they might also have been susceptible to the powers of other magicians when they did.

From the Middle Ages and into the Age of Enlightenment, theories of the Undead continued to grow and develop. Their names became more familiar—werewolf, vampire, ghoul—each one certain to strike fear into the hearts of ordinary humans.

“In order to confirm their abnormal status, many of the Undead were often accorded attributes, which defied the natural order of things . . .” Which one of the following best expresses the claim made in this statement?

Answer & solution

  • A

    The natural attributes of the Undead are rendered abnormal by changing their status.

  • B

    According the Undead an abnormal status is to reject the natural order of things.

  • Human beings conceptualise the Undead as possessing abnormal features.

  • D

    The Undead are deified in nature’s order by giving them divine attributes.

Solution

Easy

A paraphrase/claim question. Unpack the sentence: humans accorded (assigned) the Undead attributes that "defied the natural order" in order to "confirm their abnormal status." The key is who is doing the assigning — humans conceive of the Undead as abnormal; the abnormal traits are a human conceptualisation, not an inherent natural fact.

A

"The natural attributes of the Undead are rendered abnormal by changing their status." This reverses the logic — it implies the Undead had natural attributes that were then made abnormal. The sentence says abnormal attributes were assigned to confirm abnormality. Distorts the causation.

B

"According the Undead an abnormal status is to reject the natural order." This makes the abnormal status the thing that defies nature, but the sentence says the attributes defied the natural order; the abnormal status was what those attributes confirmed. Misplaces what defies nature.

C

"Human beings conceptualise the Undead as possessing abnormal features." This captures the core: humans assigned/ascribed nature-defying attributes — i.e., they conceive of the Undead as abnormal. Faithful to "were accorded attributes... which defied the natural order." Correct.

D

"The Undead are deified in nature's order by giving them divine attributes." The attributes (shape-shifting, blood-drinking, mind-control) are supernatural, not divine, and the point is that they defied the natural order, not that the Undead were placed within it. Wrong — "deified/in nature's order" contradicts the text.

Option C — the claim is that humans conceptualise the Undead as having abnormal, nature-defying features.

CAT 2022 Slot 1 VARC Q7: “In order to confirm their abnormal status, many of the Undead were often accorded attributes, which def — Solution | TheCATExam