CAT 2024 Slot 2QA Question 5

2 CirclesEasy

Three circles of equal radii touch (but not cross) each other externally. Two other circles, X and Y, are drawn such that both touch (but not cross) each of the three previous circles. If the radius of X is more than that of Y, the ratio of the radii of X and Y is

Answer & solution

  • A

    4 + 2√3 : 1

  • B

    4 + √3 : 1

  • C

    2 + √3 : 1

  • 7 + 4√3 : 1

Solution

Hard

Three equal circles touching pairwise have centres forming an equilateral triangle. Both X (larger, enclosing) and Y (smaller, inner) are concentric with that triangle's centroid. Get the centroid-to-centre distance, then X's radius is centroid distance +r+\,r and Y's is centroid distance r-\,r.

O X
1

Set up the geometry. Let each of the three equal circles have radius rr. Their centres form an equilateral triangle of side 2r2r (each pair touches externally). Let OO be the centroid. The distance from OO to any centre equals the circumradius of that equilateral triangle.

d=side3=2r3\begin{aligned} &d=\frac{\text{side}}{\sqrt3}=\frac{2r}{\sqrt3} \end{aligned}
2

Radius of the enclosing circle X. X is centred at OO and touches each circle externally from outside, so its radius reaches a far edge: RX=d+rR_X=d+r.

RX=2r3+r=r ⁣(2+33)\begin{aligned} &R_X=\frac{2r}{\sqrt3}+r=r\!\left(\frac{2+\sqrt3}{\sqrt3}\right) \end{aligned}
3

Radius of the inner circle Y. Y sits in the central gap, centred at OO, touching each circle on its near edge: RY=drR_Y=d-r.

RY=2r3r=r ⁣(233)\begin{aligned} &R_Y=\frac{2r}{\sqrt3}-r=r\!\left(\frac{2-\sqrt3}{\sqrt3}\right) \end{aligned}
4

Take the ratio. The radius rr and the 3\sqrt3 cancel.

RXRY=2+323 RXRY=(2+3)2(23)(2+3)(rationalise) RXRY=4+43+343=7+43\begin{aligned} &\frac{R_X}{R_Y}=\frac{2+\sqrt3}{2-\sqrt3}\\ &\Rightarrow\ \frac{R_X}{R_Y}=\frac{(2+\sqrt3)^2}{(2-\sqrt3)(2+\sqrt3)} \quad\text{(rationalise)}\\ &\Rightarrow\ \frac{R_X}{R_Y}=\frac{4+4\sqrt3+3}{4-3}=7+4\sqrt3 \end{aligned}
RX:RY=(7+43):1R_X:R_Y=\big(7+4\sqrt3\big):1
CAT 2024 Slot 2 QA Q5: Three circles of equal radii touch (but not cross) each other externally. Two other circles, X and Y, are draw — Solution | TheCATExam