CAT 1991QA Question 58

Data SufficiencyEasy
Passage / Data

Answer the following questions based on the information given below:

There were a hundred schools in a town. Of these, the number of schools having a play – ground was 30, and these schools had neither a library nor a laboratory. The number of schools having a laboratory alone was twice the number of those having a library only. The number of schools having a laboratory as  well as a library was one fourth the number of those having a laboratory alone. The number of schools  having either a laboratory or a library or both was 35.

Each of these items has a question followed by two statements. As the answer,

Type 1, If the question can be answered with the help of statement I alone,
Type 2, If the question can be answered with the help of statement II alone,
Type 3, If both the statement I and statement II are needed to answer the question, and
Type 4, If the question cannot be answered even with the help of both the statements.

Mr. Murthy takes the morning train to his office from station A to station B, and his colleague Mr.Rahman joins him on the way. There are three  stations C, D and E on the way not necessarily in that sequence. What is the sequence of stations?

  1. Mr. Rahman boards the train at D.
  2. Mr. Thomas, who travels between C & D has two segments of journey in common with Mr. Murthy but none with Mr. Rahman.

Answer & solution

  • A

    1

  • B

    2

  • 3

  • D

    4

Solution

Statement I alone no conclusion can be drawn.

Statement II following sequence of stations is possible

A C/D E D/C B

But, From I Mr. Rahman boards the station at D which is possible at fourth position only because Mr.  Thomas and Mr. Rahman have no common station.

Hence, 3.

CAT 1991 QA Q58: Each of these items has a question followed by two statements. As the answer, Type 1, If the question can be a — Solution | TheCATExam