CAT 2017 Slot 2VARC Question 14

Mixed PracticeEasy
Passage / Data

Answer the following questions based on the information given below.

The end of age of the internal combustion engine is in sight. There are small signs everywhere: the shift to hybrid vehicles is already under way among manufacturers. Volvo has announced it will make no purely petrol-engined cars after 2019…and Tesla has just started selling its first electric car aimed squarely at the middle classes: the Tesla 3 sells for $35,000 in the US, and 400,000 people have put down a small, refundable deposit towards one . Several thousand have already taken delivery, and the company hopes to sell half a million more next year. This is a remarkable figure for a machine with a fairly short range and a very limited number of specialized charging stations.

Some of it reflects the remarkable abilities of Elon musk, the company’s founder, as a salesman, engineer, and a man able to get the most out his factory workers and the government he deals with …Mr. Musk is selling a dream that the world wants to believe in.

This last may be the most important factor in the story. The private car is…a device of immense practical help and economic significance, but at the same time a theatre for myths of unattainable self-fulfilment. The one thing you will never see in a car advertisement is traffic, even though that is the element in which drivers spend their lives. Every single driver in a traffic jam is trying to escape from it, yet it is the inevitable consequence of mass car ownership.
The sleek and swift electric car is at one level merely the most contemporary fantasy of autonomy and power. But it might also disrupt our exterior landscapes nearly as much as the fossil fuel -engined car did in the last century. Electrical cars would of course pollute far less than fossil fuel-driven ones; instead of oil reserves, the rarest materials for batteries would make undeserving despots and their dynasties fantastically rich. Petrol stations would disappear. The air in cities would once more be breathable and their streets as quite as those of Venice. This isn’t an unmixed good. Cars that were as silent as bicycles would still be as dangerous as they are now to anyone they hit without audible warning.

The dream goes further that that. The electric cars of the future will be so thoroughly equipped with sensors and reaction mechanisms that they will never hit anyone. Just as brakes don’t let you skid today, the steering wheel of tomorrow will swerve you away from danger before you have even noticed it….

This is where the fantasy of autonomy comes full circle. The logical outcome of cars which need no driver is that they will become cars which need no owner either. Instead, they will works taxis do, summoned at will but only for the journeys we actually need. This the future towards which Uber….is working. The ultimate development of the private car will be to reinvent public transport. Traffic jams will be abolished only when the private car becomes a public utility. What then will happen to our fantasies of independence? We’ll all have to take to electrically powered bicycles.

The author points out all of the following about electric cars EXCEPT

Answer & solution

Correct answer: They will ultimately undermine rather than further driver autonomy.

  • A

    Their reliance on rare materials for batteries will support despotic rule.

  • B

    They will reduce air and noise pollution.

  • C

    They will not decrease the number of traffic jam.

  • They will ultimately undermine rather than further driver autonomy.

Solution

Easy

An EXCEPT question: three options are points the author actually makes about electric cars; the correct answer is the claim the passage does NOT make. Locate each claim in the text and eliminate it; the survivor is the answer.

A

Rare battery materials will support despotic rule. Stated directly: "the rarest materials for batteries would make undeserving despots and their dynasties fantastically rich." This IS in the passage, so it is not the answer. Eliminate.

B

They will reduce air and noise pollution. Stated: cities' air "would once more be breathable" and streets "as quiet as those of Venice." This IS in the passage. Eliminate.

C

They will not decrease traffic jams. Supported: "Traffic jams will be abolished only when the private car becomes a public utility," implying electric cars alone do not end jams. This IS in the passage. Eliminate.

D

They will undermine rather than further driver autonomy. This is a claim the passage never makes about electric cars as such; the autonomy point concerns the eventual loss of ownership, and is framed as the myth's outcome, not stated as the listed claim. As the only point not asserted, it is the EXCEPT answer. Correct.

Option D is correct: it is the one statement the author does not make, so it is the exception.

Related Mixed Practice questions

See all Reading Comprehension questions →
CAT 2017 Slot 2 VARC Q14: The author points out all of the following about electric cars EXCEPT — Solution | TheCATExam